Recharging the Street

By TEF / June 18, 2013

We’ve been asked to design everything from an equestrian center to pump stations to a nuclear medicine suite, but perhaps the most unusual assignment we’ve ever been given is to design a wall. Not just any wall, but a freestanding one—ten feet high and nearly a mile long. It posed a fascinating challenge.

PG&E asked us to put this wall around its Martin Substation, which acts as a conduit for 70 percent of San Francisco’s power. It straddles the border of Daly City and Brisbane, at the corner of Bayshore Road and Geneva Avenue. To keep it secure, the substation had long been surrounded by a chain link fence topped with barbed wire:  not very attractive.

The site is surrounded by some housing, a few motels, a gas station, and open landscape. So how do you make something that gives the required security (and resists graffiti), but that doesn’t feel like a fortress? The risk with such a huge wall is that it could seem to shut out the world with a blank, deadening expanse of masonry. After all, it had to be 4,320 feet long.

Wall facade 
We decided the wall should have a visual relationship to the long, low hills beyond. We chose two kinds of masonry block. For the wall’s exterior, we used split-face blocks, which have a lot of texture that catches the light in interesting ways. The yellow masonry blends in well with the distant hills, especially in the summer. For the wall’s interior, we used smooth-faced blocks to save costs.

Visitors along wall facade 
Then, because the ground slopes as it approaches Bayshore, we broke up the wall into segments that step down to follow the grade change. Between each segment, we inserted one of two kinds of infill panel to demarcate the change in level and add further variety. The first type of infill panel, which is a foot shorter than the wall, consists of concrete masonry units on the inside and Heath tiles set in soldier course on the outside. The second type of infill panel consists of channel glass, which lets light through during the day; at night, they are back-lit for dramatic effect.

Night shot of PG&E Wall 
Illumination comes from custom LED strips powered by five onsite photovoltaic arrays. Because the wall segments are different lengths, and the two types of infill panels alternate in an irregular fashion, they create an eccentric syncopated rhythm, avoiding a monolithic feel. And of course, everything has a special coating so that any graffiti can be easily cleaned off.

Night shot of PG&E Wall 
Usually we’re designing buildings that relate to the street rather than serve as a barrier. A security wall may sound like the most utilitarian piece of architecture, but the opportunity is there to create something that is sculptural and that relates to its surroundings. We get a charge out of that.

Photos ©2012 Bruce Damonte


Other blogs by TEF

Time for a Party Art & the Unexpected Contemporary Access Programming a Nonexistent Existing Building Learning by "Leap" and Bounds Back to the Healthcare Future Summer Reading: June Summer Reading: Final of the Series The Lantern: A Modern Café for Modern Students You Also Have to Remember to Look Down Kids on the Move The Opportunity/Constraint Tango Learning from Beale Street The Architect as Volunteer for Education and Social Justice: an interview with Amanda Hoch, Diana Rodriguez, and Maryam Rostami TEF Alumni Notes The Architecture Profession - The Interns' View TEF Alumni Notes Restoring Warnecke’s Asilomar Additions: A Conversation with Andrew Wolfram and Bridget Maley Care and Comfort: Designing Kaiser Permanente Northern California's First Inpatient Combined Medical-Psychiatric Unit A Message to our Friends and Collaborators SOLIDARITY The Language of Connection: An Interview with Artist Favianna Rodriguez Maryam Rostami on advocacy and well-being Jennifer Tulley on the entrepreneurial mind and what’s next The Art of Craft: A Conversation with Rachel Hammond, Justin Tang, and Kate Thorson Connecting People to the Waterfront: TEF’s History of Design at the Edge of the San Francisco Bay TEF and San Francisco Public Works: A Dialog with Edgar Lopez Connecting Community Service and Engagement: A Conversation with Mrunalini Kulkarni, O.J. Monegas, and Glynis Nakahara The Art of Collaboration: A Conversation with Tatiana Bilbao, Sam Miller, and E.B. Min Navigating the Future of Work in Hybrid Workplaces: A Case Study An Interview With Patrick Bell: Business Advisor to AEC Firms Giving Back at TEF TEF at A'23